Andrew Luck or RG3?

Poll from kcchiefs.com

"You be the GM - Who would YOU pick?"

Vote on the homepage of kcchiefs.com too!

In the pro ranks, no contest for me.

Luck! Not even close. Luck is a way better passer and he's pretty damn fast himself, bigger and much stronger.

I like RGIII.

Luck, no doubt about it.

I would go with neither, cause they both could be failures. We really don't know for sure. The Colts seem to be dead set thinking Luck is going to be a starter day 1 and worth it, but we never know. I surely have no faith in RGIII since he played nothing but crap defenses in college.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TecmoNightmare

I would go with neither, cause they both could be failures. We really don't know for sure. The Colts seem to be dead set thinking Luck is going to be a starter day 1 and worth it, but we never know. I surely have no faith in RGIII since he played nothing but crap defenses in college.

---

I suppose Joe Montana was going to be a failure too. He played at Notre Dame and played against one SEC team during his career (Tennessee in 1978). The SEC isn't the end all be all. Could RG3 be a bust sure but basing that on him not playing against SEC teams is kind of a bad measuring stick.