May well be on the chopping block this off season.
...Worth a trade??? If so, who/what???
Printable View
May well be on the chopping block this off season.
...Worth a trade??? If so, who/what???
I think so and draft geno smith to sit behind him for a few years. And if alex smith works out. We got our franchise qb.
Who/what do we give up for him though?
No, Alex smith had a top 5 Defense and talent surronding him. He's not good at all. Look at games where they make Alex Smith win the game with his arm
No thanks, I'd rather have Kaepernick, unfortunately so would SF.
Yea no smith unless maybe fir a 3-4 round pick.
He isn't much better then Matt. Get is a serviceable qb tests all nothing more
Alex Smith minus Harbaugh is Matt Cassel.
No thanks.
He is average and we're sick of average at the quarterback position. He is maybe a slight upgrade on Cassel but nothing more.
This year is the wrong year to have a top 3 pick and to be needing a QB.
Trade Cassel for Smith then trade Smith off before he has a chance to show what he doesnt have. You'll get more for him than Matt.
Nobody wants cassel either
I would be ok with us getting a qb in the draft and bringing in Smith and having them battle for the job as long as we have a new coaching staff. With this staff I don't think we would see that great of a difference with any QB that is realistic for us to get
Nope
Get qb second round.
NO. Just no.
I do like the idea of Alex Smith as QB
I would not trade for Smith, but if he is released, sign him.
Reaching for stars that are not even there. We missed the boat by refusing to sack up and really go for Manning.
You see where the Broncs are don;t ya?
It's been awhile since we've gone to the SF well for a QB.
Where do you rank Alex Smith among:
1. Joe Montana
2. Elvis Grbac
3. Steve Bono
If at the bottom, Id rather coax Steve Young out of retirement for another SF QB. Or maybe even Jeff Garcia.
He's not close to elite. System qb. I'd say Matt u s better. Sfr jy st h as better team and coaches.
I would take Alex Smith as a free agent, but not sure now that I would trade. I kinda on the draft Geno thought, but I just do not think the Chiefs will want to pay out the money for the first pick of the draft. I see some trading action going on. But with the new contract rules, that I not sure of, who knows what will happen.
Don't forget the new players contract has a pay scale for rookies. Players picked within the top 10 will be paid the average of the top 10 highest-paid players in that position, now yes QB is a high paid position. This deal helps prevent owners like when Al Davis paid JaMarcus Russel $39 million dollars to have the player be a “bust” in the league. There will be no more contracts like Sam Bradford’s six-year, $78 million dollar contract with him being paid $50 million dollars before ever playing a down.
alex smith is no different than cassel.
You put the right system around either one and you can win with them. we proved it in 2010. I'd rather get the right coaches in here and keep cassel than go out and get another of the same breed
you very well may be right. Me personally i think cassel is to much of a fighter to have given up on himself. And i'm not saying we stick with him but i'd rather keep him then smith and still think we need a QB in the draft if we can get the right one at the right spot