I think he would have struggled a year as the KC qb.
but hindsight is 20 20 for a reason...
:peace:
I think he would have struggled a year as the KC qb.
but hindsight is 20 20 for a reason...
:peace:
Mebbe.....mebbe not. What is certain is that he is going to come to regret joining the AFC West. Because from here on out as long as Manning plays and well beyond, the Chiefs are going to dominate the AFC West. Peyton Manning's career goes nowhere but down from here. He is not going to have a Montana comeback. The Forehead is DOOMED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Damage is done. At his point in time, there is absolutely no solution I would want Manning on the Chiefs. He is now equal to Elway. Always will be a hated Donkey.
Quite right!!!!
History has shown that QB's who win a SB with one team as a starter, have not won a SB with the 2nd team (Kurt Warner came close with The Cardinals, his 3rd team). The clock is ticking down on Manning. Would much rather have Alex Smith at this stage.
New front office, new teamQuote:
Originally Posted by brdempsey69
as some people on here said, can't bring history up
Bullsh!t !! Regimes don't have anything to do with it. History can be brought up and pointed out at any time, by anybody & I don't need anyone's permission to do so.Quote:
Originally Posted by doobs_05
Haley scared him off
Actually, Haley was gone. It was Pioli that spooked Manning off, as Pioli had orchestrated a raw deal with Bill Kuharich when Pioli first took over and it just so happens that the entire Manning family ( mostly dad Archie ) has close ties with Kuharich.Quote:
Originally Posted by kcvet
Notwithstanding, I'm not sorry that Manning did not come to KC, as KC didn't have the O-Line to protect him, anyway.
+1. We would've been sinking major money into a QB that would've been injured, and no capable backup on the roster.Quote:
Originally Posted by brdempsey69
If Manning had come here, then we would have probably been competitive last year, but I doubt we would have made the playoffs. Which means we probably would not have fired Romeo or Pioli (since the team improved). Also, as dempsey mentioned, with our OL, he would have had a hard time having success.
So that having been said, Im glad he didnt come here. Otherwise we would not have Reid and Dorsey as they would have gone to different teams in the offseason, and we would be stuck with a mediocre team due to poor coaching and drafting.
good points fer sure...Quote:
Originally Posted by jap1
was purely a hypothetical.
i get tired of the articles the media puts out, so i try and spice up the what ifs when i can.
i think the reason i made the point was the sole reason manning didnt even talk to them were because of pioli and crenel (or whoever else would coach)
id say this, if mannings departure from indy happened a two years later (assuming he was not two years older), i could see the chiefs drawing him in.
i have spent most of my adult life rooting against peyton and for eli. not gonna change now.
sorta like imagining:
what IF jim kelly was taken by the chiefs, into the 90's with smith and thomas.
:D
Absoultely. If Peyton was available this offseason, he wouldn't have totally ignored KC after we got Reid and Dorsey. The question is would Reid want Manning? Reid wants mobile QBs and control of the offense. I don't know if he wants an immobile QB that wants full control of the offense. There would be a lot of head butting. I will say this ... If manning was available this offseason, I would bet that we would have been able to get Smith for less than 2 2nds.Quote:
Originally Posted by NickheadKCAU
HONESTLY, I have some problem with winning a Super Bowl with a big asterisk attach to it. When we win our Super Bowl I want it to be a Chiefs Championship, not something that somebody else's phenom QB won (whether or not he actually won the big game). The latter scenario would never shut the critics up that the Chiefs did not amount to anything if not for Manning.
When Manning was available I was a bit excited that we had the chance to get him. But the more I thought about it, the more the above thought gnawed at me.
I have high hopes for the future of our pocket passer Tyler Bray under Reid.Quote:
Originally Posted by jap1
i cannot wait to see what bray does.