No, it's not.
So would a lot of other QB's. Manning has only won been in one Super Bowl in 12 years. The other 11 years two other QBs went to the Super Bowl.
Printable View
No question, he would help our team if he is healthy. Right now he is not and we don't know if he ever will be. And if we get Manning, in two or three years we will still need a QB. With our defense, a healthy offense and some upgrades on the O-line we can compete for a Super Bowl with a number of QB's, not just with (a healthy) Manning.