Originally Posted by
matthewschiefs
You're missing the whole point with the Colts
Don't you think if the better head coach was still there Dungy One of there biggest weapons Harrison was still there the O line was playing like they did during much of Mannings time there Edgerrin James was still there that they would have been better even without Manning. All those guys brought nothing to the table???????????????????? You really believe that? OF COURSE THEY WERE FACTORS. Losing Manning was there Death blow but they were already hit with a number of other blows they were not able to take the loss of Manning as well as they could have if all the other parts had not left.
They were good without Dungy, James and Harrison.
And again you just want to ignore the piss poor coaching Smith had as not a vaild reason??????????? So i want you to rule Vernon Davis sucks Do it he didn't play well under singletary he was sent off the field it was so bad. SO hold him to that same standard he sucks right?
Then look at the Harbaugh season, why didn't he throw for yards/touchdowns then?
It's clear as day you've made up you're mind on Smith. Alex Smith has played one drive for the Chiefs took them down for a td and what did you do. You come on going dink and dunk BLAH BLAH BLAH. Whats wrong with good start keep it up. You can't do it. You clearly can't be objective when it comes to QBs. Your track record speaks for itself to argue any further at this point would be pointless. Smith will never please you.
I judge Smith's performance from his entire career. Those that do not like to do that, and blame it on other factors look at his only full successful season with Harbaugh. When I bring up his lack of touchdowns/yards for that year, they start talking about other quarterbacks. If he meets the requirements I posted in the other thread which are very reasonable, then I will not consider the trade to be a bust.