You might not have said Fisher is a bust but you have jumped on him for EVERY mistake he has made. It's preseason in his Rookie year. Of course he's going to make mistakes and have plays that he would like back. He most likely will have some in the real season as well. Like EVERY rookie in the history of the game has. They all have rookie moments that they learn from. What decides If a player is good or bad is if he learns from those rookie moments and cuts them from his game we will see for Fisher. So far some good some bad. The niners game was HORRIBLE but not from just Fisher from the whole O line. Why single out Fisher?
The reason I have brought up Geno is trying to get through to you what I feel is a double standard. You wouldn't think it's fair the judge to judge him. I have agreed that QB is more of a developmental position but that doesn't mean that any other rookie doesn't go through a developmental time. Preseason is NEVER a good time to judge a rookie. All I'm saying is take a chill pill and let him develop
You would be perfectly reasonable if you did bring up Geno's circumstances as I was with Smith. Geno's not in a great offense it's one of the things that is hurting him. Very True. He might get MUCH better if they get him a better offense. The reason I have brought up Smith's circumstances is because they have been a factor it's not an "excuse" it's fact. That team didn't go out and bring in a whole lot of new players after the 2010 season they got a MUCH better coach and the level of play went up across the board. That to me say that coaching was the biggest issue there. And while I will agree it doesn't take all blame from Smith it does show that not all the struggles were on Alex Smith. He was not in a great situation and it hurt him. Just like Geno right now. It's fair to bring out that point.
Thank you. Bring more post like this and you won't get the hate on here you do now. A little positive talk when due can go a long way