Propose trades.
I'll start.
(A)
We get:
ILB James Laurinitis AND
(pick) #33 overall
We give:
Glenn Dorsey
Hall of Famer
Let's play, "would you do it?" (trades)
Propose trades.
I'll start.
(A)
We get:
ILB James Laurinitis AND
(pick) #33 overall
We give:
Glenn Dorsey
Hall of Famer
Morrison was tendered with a 3rd, so any team can claim him for that price if he signs an offer sheet.
Site Owner and Admin
Fo sho! I think he's one of the best NT's in the game. And I think it's the most important position in the 3-4 defense. I'm willing to spend our #5 pick on an unproven like Dan Williams. I'm definitely willing to give a mid 2nd rd pick for a proven one.Originally Posted by bwilliams
____________
Posted from my BlackBerry, PM me for Details
Site Owner and Admin
Would you do it?
Giants gets Derrick Johnson
Chiefs gets Giants 2nd rd pick
____________
Posted from my BlackBerry, PM me for Details
On the team
Yep...as much as I like DJ, for whatever reason he's not getting the PT he should be, and the 2nd round is loaded this year.
King Kong
I would say yes...my DJ jersey would be worthless to me though.
Hall of Famer
I'd rather have their late first than their late 2nd.
Site Owner and Admin
So would I, but I don't think Giants fan would. I tihnk a 2nd would get the deal done.
Star Player
Don't the Giants pick around number 15 overall?
Great Googly Moogly
RyanD82 - Twitter
Sith Master
Yes.
Dorsey won't stay happy in the 3-4 DE role, I don't believe. So may as well make the best of the situation before he can opt to leave, or become a problem within the lockerroom.
However, if I believed that he would be happy in his role, I would not make the deal.
It's a tad steeper than I would hope for. But still seems like a fair value.
I do it.
Unless the staff is happier with our current TEs than what I believe, I would probably bite on this offer too.
Yep.
His age would be a concern. But hard to pass on the opportunity to fill the NT in one easy shot.
This is the toughest choice I have seen so far.
If I believed that DJ's relationship with the staff was not salvagable, then I would do it.
But I have a feeling that they will be able to work things out.
So, I would pass on this one. But would be fearful that that decision would be a big mistake.
Hall of Famer
Here is another one:
B. Waters for an early 3rd round pick.
Not sure yet if I would do it.
Last year we questioned whether we could gat a 3rd because of his supposed locker room problems. After getting Man of the Year, I dont think another team would be worried about him being a locker room cancer.
I would only like this trade if we drafted Bulaga or Okung and moved Albert to LG. Then used one of our 3rd or the 4th round picks to grap a C to develop for a year behind Weigmann/Niswanger. Waters is older and slower, meaning he doesnt quite fit the ideal zone blocking mold. This would give us:
Okung
Albert
Weigmann/Niswanger
Lilja
O'Callaghan
Last edited by jap1; 03-16-2010 at 03:25 PM.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks