McFadden better than Charles?

[wildcat]

This is a joke. They have a poll on ESPN that asks who is the best running back in the Chiefs vs Raiders game. McFadden is getting the most votes!?

McFadden has some talent, but he never seems to stay healthy for long. If Charles was getting as many carries as McFadden per game, the stats wouldn't even look close. Charles is averaging a yard more per carry. He proved that he could be a 2000 yard type of back last year when he almost ran for 1000 yards in the final 8 games. And McFadden has already been out 2 games this year. I'm sorry, but durability is an extremely important attribute for an RB and McFadden is lacking in that department.

I don't think there is a way to link directly to the poll. If you click on the following link though, just look for "NFL: Chiefs at Raiders" in the left column:

SportsNation Polls - SportsNation - ESPN

[Connie Jo]

I wouldn't take them seriously...They have won on there that says "The Chiefs will Win The NFC West"

[CHIEFS_FN_ROCK]

I believe that Charles is in the discussion for best RB in The NFL.

Definitely the best-kept secret in The NFL.

But I do like how McFadden has looked this season. (Except for that horrible uniform. )

Mcfadden has hooked my fatsay team up!!

[hometeam]

mcsadden wishes he could run like my boy JC.

[chiefnut]

its a toss up. both are fast, quick,shifty, can make tacklers miss, but Charles has been more consistent.

[hometeam]

charles is light years faster, quicker, and shiftier. More consistent, and just plain better,

the only thing mcfadden has over charles is maybe power running, and JC has shown hes not afraid to power over guys either.

!

[Ryfo18]

charles is light years faster, quicker, and shiftier. More consistent, and just plain better,

the only thing mcfadden has over charles is maybe power running, and JC has shown hes not afraid to power over guys either.

!

No way...McFadden's knock was always that he couldn't break tackles (thought it seems he's doing better this year). Charles racks up tons of yards after first contact.