Brodie Croyle debate

[Coach]

I'd say it's safe to say this debate is done. Hope all you Cassel haters are enjoying the game.
At least Brodie played a half of football without being taken off on a stretcher

[wilqb16]

In his defense, I think most would have gone 0-9 with the team he was playing with the past few years

I agree - keep in mind, itsn't like our other QB's tore the joint up and we had a lot of them Huard, Thigpen, even Cassel last season.

Show me a bad team and I will show you a bad quarterback...

[Drunker Hillbilly]

In his defense, I think most would have gone 0-9 with the team he was playing with the past few years

I'd bet a beer on that. He is TERRIBLE.

[Canada]

I'd bet a beer on that. He is TERRIBLE.

I agree that he is terrible, but what backup QB is going to do any better?

[wilqb16]

I agree that he is terrible, but what backup QB is going to do any better?

I watched the UFL this season and I wouldn't mind us taking a look at Daunte Culpepper...

[Drunker Hillbilly]

I agree that he is terrible, but what backup QB is going to do any better?

First keep in mind that there has only been one team to go without a win and that's only 5 games more than the 11. As for the question, there are several IMO.

Vick/Kolb depending on who was starting.
John Kitna
Kerry Collins
Marc Bulger
Shawn Hill
Byron Leftwich
Charlie Batch

These are just a few that come to mind. I would bet there are several more if I were to look them up but to say Croyle sucks is an understatement. 0-11 as a starter IMO would be hard to do if you were a player with any skill at all at that level.

[Ryfo18]

First keep in mind that there has only been one team to go without a win and that's only 5 games more than the 11. As for the question, there are several IMO.

Vick/Kolb depending on who was starting.
John Kitna
Kerry Collins
Marc Bulger
Shawn Hill
Byron Leftwich
Charlie Batch

These are just a few that come to mind. I would bet there are several more if I were to look them up but to say Croyle sucks is an understatement. 0-11 as a starter IMO would be hard to do if you were a player with any skill at all at that level.

Yeah the common theme, other than Kolb, is a veteran QB that has started in the NFL before. It's a smart route to go.

[Drunker Hillbilly]

Yeah the common theme, other than Kolb, is a veteran QB that has started in the NFL before. It's a smart route to go.

Personally I think Croyle will be out of the league in a matter of a very short time but IMO it's a must to have successful experience of some sort at that position.

[Chiefster]

Personally I think Croyle will be out of the league in a matter of a very short time but IMO it's a must to have successful experience of some sort at that position.

You have spoken with wisdom beyond your years.

[billb40]

Brodie was bad the team was bad. Nuff said. Cassel is the man.

[Chiefster]

Brodie was bad the team was bad. Nuff said. Cassel is the man.

...This!