Originally Posted by
jason1981
I would put smith in the top 15 qb range and maybe top ten. I know hes not an elite qb but alot of times these elite qbs also have good wr who beats one on ones and makes the grest catch which in turns makes the qb look better as well. Aaron rodgers benifets mostly frkm this. There loaded at wr. The only qb I cam think of who won with just anybody at wr was brett farve who is my fav of all time. He had some good wr at the end but before that he didnt.
Point is we cant always judge a qb on stats alone.
Brady had moss, grownkowski, walker
Payton manning had harrison, wayne, and clark
Arron roders had genning, driver, shipley, jones, loaded
Brees has some but cant think off top of my head
Kurt warner had, isace bruce,holt, Fitzgerald
Eli manning has cruz and someone else I think
Aikmen had irvin
Steve young had rice and owens
Montana had rice and somereason I want to say jj stokes but I know he had another wr
Plus I know all of them also benefited for the sytem there in. Esp Rodgers and brady
Who has smith worked with at wr? And smith didnt have the sytem foundation and continuity of systems. Dif coaches and cordinaters and dif offenses unlike all the good qb in this league have had.
Bookmarks