When Andy Reid first came to town about the first thing he did was trade 2 2cond round draft picks for Alex Smith. Some people hated the move. Others were cautiously optimistic.
So now we have had 3 years of Alex so I figured it was time to look back on 3 years and see what we think of him. I will offer my opinions and hope y'all will too.
Alex is not Montana, Brady or any of the other truly amazing QBs the NFL has seen. He's cautious. You'll never see Alex with more picks than TDs in a season. In short he protects the ball. That is a good thing. As a Chief Alex has 30 wins and 16 losses in 46 regular season starts. That is a 65% win ratio. That's good. He's not as exciting as some QBs, but he wins games. That's good. He doesn't win them by himself and he will never be known as the master of the 4th quarter comeback or the 2 minute drill but he wins games by not making mistakes. He takes way more sacks than he should. That's bad. But at least part of that is thanks to the offensive line. He completes about 65% of his passes and averages about 7 interceptions per year. Good again. He averages about 3,355 yards per year. Nothing special.
So all that makes him a QB who is above average. But then there is the X factor. Alex averages 394 yards per season running the ball with an average of about 5.6 yards per carry. About 30% of his carries result in a first down. Mostly on 3rd down. That brings his average yards per season between passing and rushing to about 3,750 yards with an average of 9 turnovers per season.
Summary....Alex is a very good QB. He is not amazing or great, but he is still a very good QB. Most importantly perhaps, he was the RIGHT guy to get at the end of the disastrous 2012 season. Cassel HAD TO GO. There were no QBs worth a damn with the #1 pick overall that year. So we had to get a new QB. And Alex was the best one available.
I like to think that Alex is a "poor man's Roger Staubach". I'm damned happy we have Alex Smith.
Bookmarks