A poll on espn.com

[anaeelbackwards]

i saw this poll on espn and thought i would bring this up, and ask it..... and whats everyones' thoughts.....

who is the greatest quarterback in NFL history?

[DrunkHillbilly]

I love Favre but went with Montana. I don't judge just by his records because you can't know what Joe would have done if he or any others would have done had they played 17 years. Longevity doesn't equal the best IMO. Toughest yes!! What were their numbers after 10 years? Favre might not be in the top 5.

[Canada]

I love Favre but went with Montana. I don't judge just by his records because you can't know what Joe would have done if he or any others would have done had they played 17 years. Longevity doesn't equal the best IMO. Toughest yes!! What were their numbers after 10 years? Favre might not be in the top 5.

Well, I guess if you take away one of the things that makes Favre the greatest then you could argue that. Fact is Favre played 17 years and never missed a game. EVER. So yeah, I guess that shouldn't count. Joe didn't playy 17 years, couldn't play 17 years. It's not just longevity that I am counting, but it does count for something.

[DrunkHillbilly]

Well, I guess if you take away one of the things that makes Favre the greatest then you could argue that. Fact is Favre played 17 years and never missed a game. EVER. So yeah, I guess that shouldn't count. Joe didn't playy 17 years, couldn't play 17 years. It's not just longevity that I am counting, but it does count for something.

How about adding his INT's which could make him one of the worst?

[Canada]

How about adding his INT's which could make him one of the worst?

That is the one stat you have? That and he played too long? Jerry Rice dosen't have the most TDs in a season. Is he not the best WR anymore?

[DrunkHillbilly]

That is the one stat you have? That and he played too long? Jerry Rice dosen't have the most TDs in a season. Is he not the best WR anymore?

Hey, you wanted to take one away so I thought I would add one!! LOL!! My top three would actually be Montana, Brady and Favre. I can only speak about the guys I saw play.

[Chiefster]

Hey, you wanted to take one away so I thought I would add one!! LOL!! My top three would actually be Montana, Brady and Favre. I can only speak about the guys I saw play.

Good choices. I have to agree with you about Montana.

[DrunkHillbilly]

That is the one stat you have? That and he played too long? Jerry Rice dosen't have the most TDs in a season. Is he not the best WR anymore?

I kow I know, you want Flutie and Moon in there huh?????? LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[hermhater]

I survive that all the time!

Show off!

[hermhater]

I kow I know, you want Flutie and Moon in there huh?????? LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I want Flutie in there!

Representing for the little guy!

[chief31]

Kinda surprised to not see Peyton on there. Last year he was getting in that discussion.