There are some good names in that second list (Barber, & Addai especially), but there is a clear and significant difference in the two lists. There are only 2 guys on the first list out of 14 that I would consider busts, (Graham & Kevin Jones)...an argument could be made for a couple others, but at the very least all the others are quality starters.
On the second list there are at least 7 busts, and arguably 9 out of 11. (Barber & Addai are clearly quality picks, DeAngelo Williams and Julius Jones are in my opinion...)
So statistically, the first list is nearly a 90% positive draft pick, and the second list is closer to 25%...
I exempted the rookies from the analysis as their results aren't quantifiable.
I do think that Charles and Rice actually both will be quality RBs in the NFL...so the stats could improve slightly for that 2nd list.