Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 29

Thread: Herm's reasoning for starting Thigpen

  1. #1
    Member Since
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    2,246

    Default Herm's reasoning for starting Thigpen

    KANSAS CITY, Mo. -- Tyler Thigpen, the first player from Coastal Carolina selected in the NFL draft, will be the first to start at quarterback.




    The 24-year-old Thigpen will be under center on Sunday for Kansas City when the Chiefs go to Atlanta. It will be exactly 11 months after the struggling young Chiefs (0-2) last won a game.
    A 23-8 loss to the Oakland Raiders on Sunday, in which Thigpen came off the bench and finished 14-for-33, was their 11th straight regular-season defeat.
    "For what we're trying to do, I think he can do a good job of it," coach Herm Edwards said. "He'll be limited in some things but we want to take a look at him."
    After coming in for Damon Huard against Oakland, Thigpen looked every bit like the inexperienced second-year pro that he is and sent several passes glancing off the hands of defensive backs.
    But he appeared to settle down and eventually hit tight end Tony Gonzalez with a short touchdown pass and converted the two-point conversion. He also threw an interception and finished 14-for-33 for 151 yards.
    "He's another young player, a quarterback we want to look at, see where he's at. If he struggles, obviously Damon comes in," Edwards said.
    Brodie Croyle, the strong-armed but injury-prone young quarterback the Chiefs are hoping to build around, has a separated shoulder and will be out at least one more week and possibly more. Huard, a 12-year veteran and the only quarterback in Kansas City who has won in the NFL, made the start against the Raiders but came out in the first half with a sore neck.
    Now Huard is OK, but Thigpen will join several inexperienced young Chiefs who are getting a cram course in the NFL.
    "We're trying to look at young players, it's part of the process," Edwards said. "Is [Thigpen] a two? Is he a one? Is he always going to be a three? You don't know until they play, until they have an opportunity to play."
    With 15 rookies and 32 players of three years of experience or less, the Chiefs are the NFL's youngest team. Branden Albert, a rookie, will start at left tackle and be tasked with protecting Thigpen from Atlanta's John Abraham, who has four sacks in two games. Both starting cornerbacks and a starting defensive tackle are also rookies.
    The more seasoned Huard would seem to provide a better opportunity for victory. But Edwards bristled at the suggestion the Chiefs have decided to sacrifice wins in order to develop young players.
    "We're not trying to discard the season. We're not trying to not win any football games," he said.
    "We're the youngest team in football. We know that. But we're trying to develop our plan. We're trying to build a football team, and it's hard. It's not a lot of fun. We're going to try to beat the Falcons. We feel with what we're trying to do this week, we'll have a great chance to be successful."
    Thigpen helped Coastal Carolina launch its Football Championship Subdivision program. In 41 games with the Chanticleers, he completed 486-of-879 passes for 6,598 yards, with 53 touchdowns and 25 interceptions. He was the first player from his school selected as a consensus All-American.
    Drafted by Minnesota in the seventh round in 2007, he was claimed off waivers and threw only six passes for the Chiefs last season, completing two. This year during the preseason, he was 25-of-54 for 282 yards and two touchdowns and three interceptions.
    C:\Users\Master Sin\Desktop\thumb_pl_180492.jpg

  2. #11
    Member Since
    Sep 2005
    Location
    SE Kansas
    Posts
    31,643

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Coach View Post
    I agree with giving Thigpen a shot. Let's see what the kid has got. Last week was not a fair assessment. I know that Huard is not the long term solution and Croyle is hurt.

    At this point I think that one is probably as good as the other. FWIW.

  3. #12
    Member Since
    Jun 2007
    Location
    ID
    Posts
    262

    Default

    I understand Herm wanting to take a look at Thigpen. But , getting a win right now would go a long way in helping this team with confidence. We've lost 11 straight games dating back from last season, and losing has a way of wearing on players and creating a losing mindset that's hard to overcome. Let's win a couple of games, then maybe start "looking" at players. Just my opinion.
    Keeping my britches between the ditches! :character00182:

  4. #13
    Member Since
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Sexy Ville
    Posts
    1,383

    Default

    ........and I quote.."Hello!........you play........to win..the game..................YOU PLAY.......TO WIN....THE GAME!

    Huard gives us the best chance to win. So Herm is full of nothing but lip service.

    If Herm wanted to give Thig a try, fine, but he should have released Huard if he never planned on using him. Preseason is over, you give the ball to proven players.

  5. #14
    Member Since
    Sep 2005
    Location
    SE Kansas
    Posts
    31,643

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by OTR Chiefs fan View Post
    I understand Herm wanting to take a look at Thigpen. But , getting a win right now would go a long way in helping this team with confidence. We've lost 11 straight games dating back from last season, and losing has a way of wearing on players and creating a losing mindset that's hard to overcome. Let's win a couple of games, then maybe start "looking" at players. Just my opinion.
    Quote Originally Posted by Sn@keIze View Post
    ........and I quote.."Hello!........you play........to win..the game..................YOU PLAY.......TO WIN....THE GAME!

    Huard gives us the best chance to win. So Herm is full of nothing but lip service.

    If Herm wanted to give Thig a try, fine, but he should have released Huard if he never planned on using him. Preseason is over, you give the ball to proven players.
    Good points.

  6. #15
    Member Since
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Nebraska
    Posts
    7,498

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Sn@keIze View Post
    ........and I quote.."Hello!........you play........to win..the game..................YOU PLAY.......TO WIN....THE GAME!

    Huard gives us the best chance to win.
    How? He will not be able to get away from the rush!
    So Herm is full of nothing but lip service.

    If Herm wanted to give Thig a try, fine, but he should have released Huard if he never planned on using him.
    So release him and be done with it, so throw him away, and his contract! Huard is still a valuable player for us! He can still come in and play if needed!
    Preseason is over, you give the ball to proven players.
    Thig has to be the QB, I just hope that we have a game plan that will allow him to escape the defensive rush.
    Huard came in and proved that he is go to guy, as a back up QB! He can not be a starting QB, with the current O-Line! We have no choice but, move the QB out of the pocket, and create plays from that, we can not protect Huard! If he was to start, he will be out before the first quarter is done! jmo

  7. #16
    Member Since
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    2,246

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by OTR Chiefs fan View Post
    I understand Herm wanting to take a look at Thigpen. But , getting a win right now would go a long way in helping this team with confidence. We've lost 11 straight games dating back from last season, and losing has a way of wearing on players and creating a losing mindset that's hard to overcome. Let's win a couple of games, then maybe start "looking" at players. Just my opinion.
    I've been worried about this since the rebuilding took shape. Herm wanting to "get guys in the game" and "see how this kid does" just screams to me "I don't care about winning right now." You are 100% right about the losing mindset.

    IMO, even if it means some of the younger guys lose some playing time, we need to win a game just to win one and get momentum. Though, it doesn't matter much anymore, may as well see if these guys can play and change the course of negative momentum.
    C:\Users\Master Sin\Desktop\thumb_pl_180492.jpg

  8. #17
    Member Since
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Nebraska
    Posts
    7,498

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Three7s View Post
    I've been worried about this since the rebuilding took shape. Herm wanting to "get guys in the game" and "see how this kid does" just screams to me "I don't care about winning right now." You are 100% right about the losing mindset.

    IMO, even if it means some of the younger guys lose some playing time, we need to win a game just to win one and get momentum. Though, it doesn't matter much anymore, may as well see if these guys can play and change the course of negative momentum.
    Yes we need a win! Huard is a vet, He has proven that he is prepared to come in and take over if the starting QB gets hurt, so he is good to go most anytime he not hurt. Thig is young, he does not know how to prepare to be a backup QB, So having him take all the snaps at practice with the first team, he will be more prepared to be successful, if he fails, Huard the vet will be prepared to come in! But we need Thig to run outside the pocket and create plays if needed! We need a play maker at QB......... I hope he can do it.

  9. #18
    Member Since
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Miami, Florida
    Posts
    41

    Default

    we have lyk 5 QB's...letz c....croyle, huard, thigpen, martin, and hagans...i lyked how brodie wuz throwing da ball in da 1st week (b4 he got hurt).a healthy brodie is da best qb we got....but we all know HUARD IS DA BEST OUT OF DEM ALL!!!!!

  10. #19
    Member Since
    Jun 2007
    Location
    ID
    Posts
    262

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by arrowheadGoon305 View Post
    we have lyk 5 QB's...letz c....croyle, huard, thigpen, martin, and hagans...i lyked how brodie wuz throwing da ball in da 1st week (b4 he got hurt).a healthy brodie is da best qb we got....but we all know HUARD IS DA BEST OUT OF DEM ALL!!!!!
    I agree with the Croyle point. I also, liked the way Croyle was throwing the ball in the first game. But, he's got to stay healthy and he's had a history of being injured. Just check his college days to verify that. If he can't stay on the field then he's no good to us.
    Keeping my britches between the ditches! :character00182:

  11. #20
    Member Since
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Ventura, Ca.
    Posts
    2,607

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by arrowheadGoon305 View Post
    we have lyk 5 QB's...letz c....croyle, huard, thigpen, martin, and hagans...i lyked how brodie wuz throwing da ball in da 1st week (b4 he got hurt).a healthy brodie is da best qb we got....but we all know HUARD IS DA BEST OUT OF DEM ALL!!!!!
    Listen, you do not lend yourself to knowing what you are talking about by writing in this fashion. Why not impress people with your intelligence instead of writing like this.

    The leet speak crap really is annoying!

Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •