0
Chiefs have QB decision ahead
By ADAM TEICHER
The Kansas City Star
Will Kansas City pick the potential of Brodie Croyle (left) or the experience of Damon Huard?
RIVER FALLS, Wis. | When forced to choose a starting quarterback between Brodie Croyle and Damon Huard, the Chiefs will have hour after hour of practice video to aid in the process.
Some of that video will be more valuable, like that from two joint weekend practices with the Minnesota Vikings. The teams will get together Friday night at Vikings camp in Mankato, Minn., and then have a return engagement in River Falls the following night.
After almost a week of training, the Chiefs have come to know themselves too well. Cornerbacks recognize pass routes and can jump into passing lanes without fear of getting burned. Quarterbacks recognize pass coverages and can avoid trouble.
Against the Vikings, everything is new.
“Those practices definitely will help us,” said Dick Curl, the Chiefs’ quarterbacks coach. “All of a sudden you’re going against a different team and they’re going to do some different things than we might be doing. We’ll see maybe some different looks, different types of schemes. That’s good for us. In some ways, it’s like a preseason game.”
Publicly, the Chiefs are being noncommittal about what they’ve seen from Croyle and Huard through the first week of training camp. Work between the two has been split almost evenly.
The Chiefs are also trying to give them similar plays so they can better make a side-by-side comparison.
“We’re trying to be fair to both of those guys,” Curl said.
Privately, the Chiefs are so pleased with Croyle that it’s hard to imagine he won’t be their choice as long as he continues his current arc. He has demonstrated a better ability to make all of the necessary throws than any Chiefs quarterback in a long time.
An example came in a recent practice with the Chiefs inside the opposing 10-yard line. Croyle had the narrowest of windows in which to fit a pass to Jeff Webb over the middle. His release, zip and accuracy were all perfect and the Chiefs had a touchdown.
Former Chiefs starting quarterback Trent Green certainly couldn’t have made the throw. Huard probably couldn’t, either.
“Not only did he get rid of it real quick, but he put the ball in a position where only Jeff could catch it,” Curl said. “His accuracy has been really good. The thing that will determine a lot of how far we can go with him is his decision-making when he has (defenders) running at him.”
Croyle didn’t fare so well in a recent practice with blitzing safety Bernard Pollard running at him. Croyle tried to force his pass to Michael Bennett, but Pollard tipped and intercepted it.
“It’s little things like don’t try to force things down the field when you have a back who can get you to second and 5,” Croyle said. “I’ve probably been told that more times than anything in this camp.”
Huard has been hanging on in the NFL for several years, so it’s wise never to count him out. He played better than the Chiefs dared hope last year when they lost Green.
“Certainly there’s a sense of urgency for me,” he said. “Like every other year I’ve gone to training camp, you’re always fighting for something. Whether it’s to be the backup or make the team, or this year to be the starter. I’ve been in this situation before, so it’s kind of what pro football is about. It’s all about competition.”
Croyle’s potential and inexperience make him the riskier pick. Huard is the safer choice. The Chiefs are certain what they would get from him.
“You believe in yourself and more importantly your teammates know they can win with you,” Huard said. “I hope that gives me an edge. But again, I’m 34 and Brodie’s 24. That’s the reality of it. We’ll go out there and compete every day and both of us probably are going to have to play this season at some point anyway. We both know we’re fighting to learn the system and the gain the respect of our teammates and make this team better every day.”
Coach Herm Edwards hasn’t set a date for deciding on a starting quarterback but has said he would like to have one halfway through the four exhibition games.
“You’ll see the separation as we go through the preseason,” he said.
THAT quarterback is NOT a Pro Bowl quarterback. Never was and never will be.
I completely agree with this. Everyone was talking about switching up QB's mid-season, I just wanted to throw out another scenario. I'm all for starting Croyle and letting the season be his. Everyone calls him the QB of the future. With the Chiefs, the future never seems to get here.
Everything happens for a reason.
That's why I say 2 choices:
1) If Herm feels Huard is bettter: try to win now with Huard and if he fails, switch to Croyle.
2) If Herm feels Croyle is better: let Croyle have the season, even if he struggles.
If you don't make the play-offs, there is not much difference for next season between 8-8 and 5-11. So gain from the experience, move up a few slots in the draft, have 3 easier games next year and take your lumps.
But just don't start Croyle and bring in Huard in the middle after the play-offs are out of reach. Long term there is no gain...
You can only have one favorite team. There are no "second favorites".
-- Chris, resident of Arrowhead East (St. Louis)
I'm all for the youth movement especially at the QB position, but as the knock that has been on him, can BC go the distance? 16 games in the NFL...I mean I have not really seen him this year. you all are alot closer, has he truly bulked up some? Personally I hope it works out for him. I'll pull for whoever is at the helm,as long as he bleeds red and gold!!!!! on another note:
When Joe Montana joined the 49ers as a rookie from Notre Dame in 1979, fellow draftee Dwight Clark mistook him for a free-agent kicker. Who wouldn't? By NFL standards, Montana looked a bit fragile, and his unassuming demeanor hardly demanded attention. -Phil Barber cbssportsline
This is the only thing I hate about Pre-Season. Not knowing who is going to start. I like to know things now.
Official thread killer I have heard.
Bookmarks