How Oregon Coach Chip Kelly Can Spark ‘Moneyball’ Revolution In NFL
Friday, November 2, 2012 3:10 pmWritten by: Tim Livingston
10.7K 3491 63ShareThis
For those who know Oregon coach Chip Kelly’s mannerisms, his trademark smirk was in full effect. This was during the Ducks’ first real "test" this season, a home game against Arizona, and they saw their opening drive end when the Wildcats stuffed quarterback Marcus Mariota for a 4-yard loss on fourth and 1.
After the tackle, Arizona linebackers rejoiced with passionate fist pumps and jumped on top of each other like frogs mating. The Wildcats were getting the ball in field-goal range (Oregon’s 35-yard line) with a chance to take an early lead on the No. 3-ranked Ducks, but more importantly, they had just won their first battle against Kelly’s virtually unstoppable "Quack Attack" offense. Yet, as he paced the Oregon sideline, Kelly reeked of smugness.
Kelly had set the tone, and his demeanor made clear that he was unperturbed by the outcome of the previous play. Kelly goes for it on fourth down consistently and confidently. Oregon’s players, on both sides of the ball, comprehend Kelly’s strategy. The Ducks didn’t convert, but they didn’t care, because they knew the following equations would hold true:
Oregon’s offense > Arizona’s defense
Chip Kelly > Every other coach in college football
Oregon’s next fourth-and-short came late in the second quarter when the Ducks faced a fourth-and-2 on their own 34-yard line. Kelly went for it again, and this time Kenjon Barner ran for six yards and a first down. Oregon went on to a 16-play scoring drive that ate up all but 28 seconds of the first half and totally deflated Arizona’s defense. Oregon went on to score 36 points in the second half en route to a 49-0 win.
Those fourth down calls epitomize Kelly’s aggressiveness but what the average football fan doesn’t realize is that Chip’s play-calls (the fourth down tries, fake punts, two-point conversions, etc.) are almost always the correct mathematical decision. Like Paul DePodesta and Billy Beane did in baseball, Kelly’s genius comes from exploiting arithmetic that other coaches are too naïve to acknowledge.
Six years ago, Chip Kelly was the offensive coordinator at the University of New Hampshire. In January, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers fired coach Raheem Morris and targeted Kelly as his replacement. Although Chip turned down the Bucs’ offer because he had "unfinished business" at Oregon (read: national championship), Kelly’s ascent through the coaching ranks has been nothing short of extraordinary. From an assistant at a Division I-AA school to turning down an NFL head coaching job in six years. Not bad, Chip. Not bad.
We will never share your email address. You can unsubscribe anytime.
It’s a shame Kelly didn’t take his talents to Tampa because he would have single-handedly changed the way the NFL game is played by this point in the season. He’d turn the focus away from concussions and make people realize that football is a chess match, a game of strategy, and when played correctly, a beautiful thing.
Here’s an example of how the NFL works. The Miami Dolphins were 1-15 in 2007 and started off the ’08 season 0-2. In Week 3, they instituted the Wildcat offense, finished 11-3, and made the playoffs. Pundits argued that the Wildcat was a gimmick, that defenses would adjust, that it would never last, and they were partially right. Defenses did adjust, yet somehow, five years later, more than fifty percent of NFL teams have a version of the Wildcat in their playbook.
Why does this matter? Because when something catches on in the NFL, everyone jumps on the bandwagon. At first they refute it, call it a fluke, and then eventually, when a team wins 11 out of 14 games after losing 17 of its previous 18, they realize that there might be something to the newfound strategy and hurry to insert into their playbooks. The NFL is a cat and mouse league.
This is how and why Chip Kelly will modernize the game in the same way that Billy Beane’s triumphs showed baseball executives that getting on base is more important than batting average. Soon enough Kelly will take over an NFL team. (A national championship is possible this season, but those Bama boys are a different breed and that Saban fella is a pretty incredible coach in his own right.) Whenever Kelly does enter the league, he’ll play the game aggressively, with "aggressively" meaning in a mathematically logical fashion. By the end of the season every coach will be going for it on fourth down, attempting fake punts, fake field goals, two-point conversions, and they’ll likely do all of this oblivious to the fact that there’s astounding mathematical evidence supporting the decisions they’re making.
They’ll just see Chip Kelly’s team lighting up the scoreboard and follow suit because … well, 90 percent of NFL coaches are followers.
The fact that the league has ignored such rudimentary math for so long and that the average team’s miscalculations account for approximately one loss per year (we’ll get to that later) is mind-boggling. How has there not been a revolt? How have millions of fans watched silently as NFL coaches, refusing to stray from orthodoxy, continually punt away games (pun very much intended)? How has there not been a boycott?
These men are at the height of their profession and haven’t utilized information that’s been available for more than 10 years. It’s the same exact thing that happened in baseball, but in this case, Bill James comes in the form of astrophysicist Chuck Bower and his partner Frank Frigo.
Frigo and Bower invented the Zeus computer program, which takes fourth-down situations such as the ones Oregon had against Arizona, and and runs them to conclusion as many as a million times to determine the optimum play-call. The system incorporates the teams’ characteristics, ball position, yards to first down, clock, and timeouts. Needless to say, these guys are smart.
Complex algorithms aside, the outcomes are incredibly simple. Zeus tells us that teams should almost always go for it on fourth and short, attempt more onsides kicks, go for two-point conversions, in other words, do all the things that Chip Kelly does on a routine basis.
But the most important thing to take away from Zeus’ findings is that the math isn’t even close. The numbers are so overwhelming that teams that kick field goals on fourth and short at the 20-yard line aren’t just wrong, they’re so wrong it’s ludicrous. For the Texas Hold ‘Em players out there, kicking a field goal in that situation is like folding pocket aces pre-flop against a smaller pocket pair. You’re conceding when you’re the overwhelming favorite. Even if the guy hits his set and wins the hand, you don’t have any regrets. You know you made the right call and that you’ll win the hand a majority of the time. NFL teams kick the field goal and "take the points" virtually every time when in reality a field goal kicker (like a punter) should only be used in times of desperation. When it’s fourth and 15, for example.
Note: Zeus breaks down its calculations into GWC or "Game Winning Chance." By going for the field goal in the previous example — fourth and 1 at the 20-yard line — a team decreases its chances of winning by X percent. Since there are so few offensive plays in the average game (usually around 70-90 depending on the team) every punt or field goal attempt chosen incorrectly can have a profound effect on the outcome of the game.
Here’s an example of how the abstract concept of "momentum" carries far more weight with NFL authorities than concrete mathematics.
It’s the first round of the 2009 AFC playoffs and the Chargers have a 7-0 lead against the Jets. The Chargers have fourth and inches at their own 47-yard line with a little more than nine minutes left in the 2nd quarter.
What does Chargers coach Norv Turner decide to do? He decides to punt of course! And the Chargers, as you may remember, had one of the best offenses in the league that season, not to mention that Philip Rivers, or any other quarterback for that matter, can convert a 6-inch sneak 99 percent of the time.
From what you just read, you’re fully aware this was a preposterous decision, but Phil Simms, who was announcing the game, pontificated for several minutes that Turner made the right call because the Chargers couldn’t risk losing momentum. He wouldn’t stop talking about the importance of momentum and how the Chargers would instantly lose it, whatever "it" may be, had they gone for the first down and not converted. No mention of the momentum that would have been created had the Chargers converted the fourth down, which they would have done easily.
A couple of weeks ago during the MNF game we saw the Chiefs hit a couple of plays in the play action game and then stop doing it and settle for run to the right over and over
This season Mccluster has gotten a few chances running the football and has made some plays and then they stop useing him
Just more to show how horrible this coaching staff is
My husband and I are leaving at midnight tonight and making the 8 hour drive to KC to come to the chiefs game!! We are looking for some fun people to tailgate with! If anyone cares to extend their tailgate party to us, it would be greatly appreciated! Please either message me on here or on h o t m a i l, k_devivo is where you can find me. We are 31 and 33, and I promise we are fun!!
Denver Broncos (7-3)
Sunday, November 25, 12:00PM Central Time
Arrowhead Stadium, Kansas City, KS
Watch online: Kansas City Chiefs vs Denver Broncos Live Stream Online
At least other teams are struggling this year.
On this play, Sanchez tries to hand off the ball to his RB but apparently the RB forgot this was a running play. Sanchez improvises and tries to run the ball upfield and gets a mouth full of his offensive lineman’s butt, then fumbles the ball for a TD.
This was all part of a period of time where New England scored 3 TD’s in 55 seconds.
Not even Cassel can claim ownership of a play this bad.
- This RSS feed URL is deprecated
- Chiefs had interest in WR Kenny Britt but he chose the Patriots, per report - Arrowhead Pride (blog)
- Chris Jones saved the Chiefs' season with a dominant performance last week - SB Nation
- Oakland Raiders news: Pure frustration after Kansas City Chiefs loss - Just Blog Baby (blog)
- Former Chief Larry Johnson says he can't recall playing two of his NFL seasons - Kansas City Star (blog)
- Updated NFL odds Week 15: Chiefs are now underdogs vs. Chargers - Arrowhead Pride (blog)
- Dillon Gordon replaces Damien Mama on Kansas City Chiefs' practice squad - Arrowhead Addict